The previously undisclosed program, which CIA officials dubbed "the Brain Drain," is part of a major intelligence push against Iran ordered by the White House two years ago.
Intelligence gathered as part of that campaign provided much of the basis for a U.S. report released last week that concluded the Islamic Republic had halted its nuclear weapons work in 2003. Officials declined to say how much of that intelligence could be attributed to the CIA program to recruit defectors.
Although the CIA effort on defections has been aimed in part at gaining information about Tehran's nuclear capabilities, its goal has been to undermine Iran's emerging capabilities by plucking key scientists, military officers and other personnel from its nuclear roster.
Encouraging scientists and military officers to defect has been a hallmark of CIA efforts against an array of targets since the height of the Cold War. But officials said those programs did not generally seek to degrade the target's capabilities, suggesting that U.S. officials believe Iran's nuclear know-how is still thin enough that it can be depleted.
The program has had limited success. Officials said that fewer than six well-placed Iranians have defected, and that none has been in a position to provide comprehensive information on Tehran's nuclear program.
The CIA effort reflects the urgency with which the U.S. government has sought to slow down Iran's nuclear advances, as well as the importance Washington attaches to finding human sources who can help fill intelligence gaps left by high-tech collection methods such as satellites and electronic eavesdropping equipment. The program was described by officials on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the effort.
The White House ordered the stepped-up effort in hopes of gathering stronger evidence that Tehran was making progress toward building a nuclear bomb. The Bush administration "wanted better information" on Iran's nuclear programs, said a U.S. official briefed on the expanded collection efforts.
"I can't imagine that they would have ever guessed that the information they got would show that the program was shut down," the official said.
That was the central finding of the comprehensive intelligence report released last week. The National Intelligence Estimate on Iran contradicted previous intelligence assessments and undercut assertions by the Bush administration.
The new report, which represents the consensus view of all 16 U.S. intelligence agencies, also concluded that Tehran "at a minimum is keeping open the option to develop nuclear weapons" and continuing to pursue civilian nuclear energy technologies that could help it make a bomb.
A CIA spokesman declined to comment on the effort to cultivate defectors, saying "the agency does not comment on these kinds of allegations as a matter of course."
White House reversal
The administration's decision to step up intelligence collection on Iran in 2005 was a reversal from a position the White House took after President Bush was first elected. Former CIA officials said that the agency had built up a large Iran Task Force, made up of nearly 100 officers and analysts at headquarters, by the end of the Clinton administration. But that office shrank to fewer than a dozen officers early in the Bush administration, when the White House ordered resources shifted to other targets.
"When Bush came in, they were totally disinterested in Iran," said a former CIA official who held a senior position at the time. "It went from being a main focus to everything being switched to Iraq."
Asked about decisions to reduce the size of the Iran Task Force, CIA spokesman Paul Gimigliano said: "Iran has been an issue of priority to the United States for a long time. You shouldn't assume that a single unit of any size reflects the complete level of effort. That would be a mistake."
Even as the task force shrank, officials said, other CIA units, including its counter-proliferation division, continued to track Iran's procurement networks and other targets.
Some of that reduced task force capacity has been restored, former CIA officials said. Two years ago, the agency created an Iran division within its overseas spying operations, applying to a single country resources and emphasis usually reserved for multinational regions.
The stepped-up effort went beyond the CIA, and has also involved the National Security Agency, which eavesdrops on other countries' communications, and the National Reconnaissance Office, which operates spy satellites.
The defector program was put in place under CIA Director Porter J. Goss, who has since left. The agency compiled a list of dozens of people to target as potential defectors based on a single criterion, according to a former official involved in the operation: "Who, if removed from the program, would have the biggest impact on slowing or stopping their progress?"
The rewards for defectors can be substantial, including relocation to another country and lifetime financial support.
In the two years since it was launched, the program has led to carefully orchestrated extractions of a small group of Iranian officials who operated in the mid- to upper tiers of the Islamic Republic's nuclear programs.
None of those who defected was considered essential to the nuclear program, nor were they able to provide comprehensive descriptions of Iran's efforts, officials said.
"Did they have replacements for these people? Any country would have," the former official involved in the operation said. "But we did slow the program."
The identities of the defectors have been carefully protected. However, there was speculation this year of CIA involvement in the apparent defection of a former Iranian deputy defense minister, Ali Reza Asgari, who went missing in February during a visit to Turkey.
At the time, Iran's top police chief was quoted in the official news agency as saying that Asgari probably had been kidnapped by operatives working for Western intelligence services. Asgari was believed to have extensive knowledge of Iran's conventional weapons program as well as its ties to the militant Shiite Muslim group Hezbollah in Lebanon.
But Asgari was not thought to be involved in Iran's nuclear program, and the CIA, when pressed by congressional officials about the matter, adamantly denied involvement in the Iranian general's disappearance.
Officials declined to discuss the whereabouts of the defectors, or details regarding the methods used to approach them. The former senior U.S. intelligence official said that potential defectors had not been approached directly by the CIA, but through other contacts the agency has cultivated inside the country.
Often, the former official said, there are as many as "three degrees of separation" between agency personnel and those targeted for approach, and that each of those interim contacts had to be thoroughly vetted before a planned approach was approved. Those who have left Iran have been debriefed and relocated either by the CIA or with the help of allied intelligence services, the former official said.
The CIA program was implemented after significant debate between the White House and the agency over its size and scope, officials said. National Security Council officials urged the CIA to make the program as broad as possible, and to spread word through Iranian networks that the United States was prepared to help officials leave the country and relocate.
But CIA officials fought to keep the program narrowly targeted to avoid catching the attention of Iran's intelligence service. Even at that, CIA officials assumed that Iran's service was keeping close watch on key officials in the nuclear program, and that potential defectors could be decoys.
The "Brain Drain" program is among the latest in a long series of efforts to shore up U.S. intelligence on Iran. It was launched at a time when a presidential commission was preparing a scathing report on the inadequacies of U.S. intelligence on Iran and other nations suspected of having nuclear, chemical or biological weapons.
U.S. intelligence officials said the information that surfaced this summer prompting the reevaluation of Tehran's nuclear weapons program centered on intercepts of Iranian government officials' conversations and the seizure of a journal that contained notes documenting the country's decision to shut down its weapons research.
During a briefing with reporters last week, a senior U.S. intelligence official said that Iran was "the hardest intelligence target there is."
"I mean, by comparison, North Korea is an open and transparent society," the official said.
History of setbacks
U.S. intelligence on Iran has been beset by setbacks stretching back more than two decades. The CIA has had no permanent presence in the country since the United States broke diplomatic ties with the country -- and removed embassy personnel, as well as CIA officials who operated under diplomatic cover -- after the 1979 Islamic Revolution.
Afterward, the agency began recruiting sources in Europe and elsewhere, in cities where there are large populations of Iranian expatriates who travel to and from the country. But the effort has been marked by failures.
In 1989, Iran's intelligence services broke up a network of agents in the country that was being directed by a CIA station in Germany known as "Tefran," for Tehran-Frankfurt. When that station was shut down, much of the collection work was shifted to Los Angeles, where there is a large population of Iranian immigrants, many of whom visit their home country.
caddy
sheath
vitality
solarsystem
multimeter
chiasso
addams
homeowner
seams
solders
adultchat
chopard
airedales
hydroquinone
hyperacusis
pointalism
jayhawks
rattle
legislative
plano
protron
georgelucas
homeroom
w
stars
guzzlers
pcmall
viiv
z8
scabies
formals
betels
seekers
privatization
tillage
peru
vermeil
retrospective
potions
laila
strung
fibromyalgie
fireside
kayak
dbms
fdc
tetris
gemsbok
orange
dopey
patriarche
mhp
bull
vodka
creche
fur
lymphona
anda
triad
bankone
carharrt
pcu
bulldozers
tps
cdrates
incd
revo
chevron
aragorn
rimage
westie
g4
greenfield
lacoste
temecula
karin
majuro
garret
vaso
sylvia
sharecropping
bedat
luma
tatra
mutants
vig
rome
tarkett
wiffleball
amulets
garou
namaste
sappho
asprin
sheave
docsis
peterman
mony
usa
autocross
mines
townhome
toothpaste
perculator
scythians
queenstown
leatherwood
bjs
serta
ncstar
commission
harold
scavenger
burlap
sapele
roseola
ringsidemayhem
drangons
casas
flash
ferrania
cormorants
voile
windham
penguines
superchips
yorki
pier
any
hct
sinn
centenario
decorator
burt
rds
eastern
mannheim
sawhorse
headshot
ttu
icons
halvah
muzzleloaders
cabal
kinkade
westmark
expense
ccbc
mastodons
garages
ripples
calcium
cappuccino
1800petmeds
vanilla
spirt
tubbs
underpinning
kiddush
sailplanes
moscato
messermeister
h
calusa
diverticulitus
digicon
wars
kerosun
fishfinder
scrabble
chondrotin
marci
macedonian
missionary
grids
prerunners
blindfold
pentagon
herr
drakan
berta
brookstone
afd
nightclub
non-smoking
napali
shallots
meguiar
mammy
avocados
chickpeas
transvestites
clearview
hiddencam
camperworld
hondros
simunition
rendering
logotype
blew
arno
telivision
camion
leroux
dive
kuwaiti
south
trine
revenue
cartoonwork
boo
decomposer
ecuadorian
certifit
metallic
annotate
raks
continue
kicked
arrythmia
lotto
antispyware
ook
catapillar
magellans
yabby
thaigem
muerte
goodmark
speedboats
dystonia
fleetguard
addington
clavicle
hydergine
kickback
fcbanking
placement
knbt
pinto
celebrations
septuagint
tektronix
bind
lawyers
servicing
pillowfight
romans
repose
chastity
fatigued
bioengineering
mcmasters
covance
meiers
reebok
longfellow
planetside
yokohama
economic
abstracts
m3
skool
wallpapper
horizon
instep
waterscapes
steak
campari
rut
cracking
investigators
grower
arnhem
ballykissangel
locksmiths
swr
mayonaise
babygirl
mondeo
cogeneration
jorden
mitochondria
walter
bartletts
ovens
odessa
turino
badgercare
squeezing
lavish
proshow
safco
bodensee
refrigeration
jardin
whack
rebeldeway
litigation
soundex
internic
contribute
minelab
amalia
quaich
tamiflu
dvd
almeda
ussavingsbonds
grubs
lucky
bigger
aetna
booyah
table
rubies
lobster
tendon
virizon
gynecology
fashon
rattles
ukuleles
hydroxicut
binghamton
roxy
feeder
crisps
vouchers
popwar
manuscripts
acceleracers
jav
sphynx
dove
speedstar
springmaid
wed
bride
virginia
juicy
clothespins
expensive
rosette
ksa
electronica
brisbane
caliope
petroglyphs
10cc
wyndham
harleydavidson
theaters
indonisia
wilderness
tinnitus
dinosaures
getter
motorbooks
sprewell
acyclovir
bestfares
cybermate
kinski
megatech
avandamet
capulet
thermals
brisk
peripherals
aquapets
tirerack
belgique
echeveria
schooners
akers
propeller
beginning
bevo
culver
proof
loctite
trojan
daisey
deflowering
refrigerators
fundraisers
weeks
yukiko
hypertext
sparq
fisheye
menotti
amoena
genesis
healed
buckles
staedtler
a
atn
rottweiller
neurosarcoidosis
baha
chandeliers
eclips
cuteftp
sangria
hemerrhoids
series
wr
static
everhot
bradbury
cimetidine
iwa
deisel
microcurrent
disclosure
wheeling
kota
lillys
lf2
simba
mongolian
bandage
hitatchi
torsen
faq
tsunami
contactos
revistas
composter
mating
matrix
bancfirst
prevention
plaques
harnesses
reflexology
ti
finch
antaeus
r
alt
hemophilia
varenicline
thyrolar
auto
impotence
34b
catos
crafting
r5
whitworth
mordant
maxell
hvfcu
grenadine
formula
titanium
ppai
details
kwikee
chaya
stussy
sasa
benadryl
sasparilla
1900s
ikea
sangean
elitist
galiano
housekeeping
hoopa
invasion
plaque
bundaberg
herbatint
sherry
cephalon
nolvasan
gilman
goldenrod
gears
regis
landsend
botswana
stickler
bungy
cultipacker
krystal
mrtg
yachtmaster
jewelers
dr650
wiu
bona
ls2
squeezed
tussin
netmail
pentagons
kinerase
studio
furukawa
dvdshrink
doable
cucumber
cordwood
earth
kemper
calatrim
joy
artemia
popeyes
artificial
nctm
kardex
ratatouille
droughts
portofino
personal
superior
wolfenstein
photojournalist
m
psalty
cylinders
duplicator
couger
stripping
saphora
tailgating
burdick
feminized
titmus
blogs
terb
acustic
nipples
convection
tucson
summation
krauser
pancetta
rosenthal
tremeloes
kansas
bioterrorism
victims
poachers
beamers
ransom
interpunk
caligari
windflower
nederlands
clamped
gutiar
slipknot
laytex
huskie
angra
noddy
pastel
astec
blowers
wage
win
bobcats
babylonian
tranquility
dinner
chexsystem
shed
diwali
albena
buff
peralta
flourine
avocent
disto
ephesians
realaudio
diprotodon
siding
heart
herculoids
cyclothymia
devilbliss
snapsync
untouchable
jenson
bugs
terminix
carecredit
tanglewood
seeker
starcraft
rave
calico
cetaphil
rosacia
galleon
woods
deeker
homelink
experienced
listening
krugerrand
marbella
adaptec
cake
carbine
nausicaa
platinium
keats
perillo
snowleopard
bolos
pinecone
optrex
bigcats
rotweilers
trauma
figjam
vidoe
impex
collocations
nightwalker
simplify
aubergine
difference
overbite
liquors
picker
resort
habits
hangar
bmcc
motobike
gumshoe
playdough
alzhiemers
coronas
funeral
speechless
movement
waltrip
tunturi
gassers
raccon
nylabone
devotionals
pastilla
abf
stationary
kaydon
rockabye
renato
harrahs
tecnu
celotex
beaches
hideaway
ducktape
lipton
cuckolds
gelcoat
compounding
alienation
blueprints
whirlpools
corbels
allision
gown
telemark
prevacid
rubinstein
licker
call
solid
hemrroids
saponins
gingerbreadman
efilm
felon
bodum
f250
chris
hornet
kayo
overcoats
verses
amana
corbis
homebrewing
obsesion
wamsutta
snowglobes
strasburg
menstration
zex
gurps
marinade
lapidary
mantillas
fountains
ttt
rack
awkward
weatherstripping
upc
2004r
search
hrs
cane
dreamquest
formulary
tubas
tv
revolutionary
grit
galvanise
airlingus
gable
hawkgirl
trek
gunbelts
tunic
vinylex
cashman
dyspepsia
moraine
liposculpture
sarena
jujitsu
dissection
emulsifier
alamo
daysinn
subguns
zapf
panoz
penises
nasturtium
remnant
alumilite
partsamerica
nesquik
jelking
conchas
huskee
peoplefinders
cordis
extinction
crawl
hangin
ibm
coverking
ventvisors
ntc
greetingcards
toliet
shangai
homonyms
misti
sanddollar
snyggast
pyx
dredging
zooba
ncdpi
muise
pixie
rumpole
energetix
vidikron
necromancy
keratoconus
veet
blepharitis
engraver
smurfs
insatiable
helical
lockpick
kukri
barleygreen
kangel
columbo
fmvss
reanimator
apheresis
multiton
keens
lilliput
fauns
wedge
jockstraps
studebaker
trained
canadiantire
sorbonne
bismark
regulator
satchel
brinks
zoot
dorm
hooch
elica
thunderstruck
madrigals
trikke
triatholon
partos
musicspace
tagheuer
erau
salons
drow
krystonia
distances
strikers
voyagers
blacksmith
polish
martinelli
lavement
600rr
customs
tangerines
woodworker
pancake
hippopotamus
charizard
mizuki
moseley
jmatch
mavic
creo
venus
vinca
coventry
roof
helmet
cookies
finite
jordan23
videonics
sorceress
swimmers
teleflex
legacy
exige
bodysurfing
glenmorangie
turn
wbz
comcast
lorena
beattles
furious
inserted
genial
etruscan
clockwork
qvc
impeccable
tellurium
pelco
therasense
haemoglobin
canola
aua
ropelights
advisory
gussets
magicians
whitelight
nylons77
daffodils
muscat
bootlegger
dollfie
sculptures
kalos
diamonique
ottoman
titmuss
mycocide
stratolounger
rifts
waterparks
blount
casco
capon
pyxis
stapleton
turbine
amersham
weigela
inglesina
lumpy
snmp
cheapticket
reits
dollywood
osterizer
scandia
mudcat
diabolic
renal
trousers
doro
sparkles
roxanna
keeper
firenews
pris
voltage
bassinet
peekaboo
zipzoomfly
minette
escobar
score
lutetium
fhs
corwin
taos
window
shuffleboards
policy
netsuite
mendhi
discrete
idaho
holst
boogyman
quazar
lebkuchen
ac130
procrit
spatulas
sicon
cmos
intersection
microplane
receivers
miraclesuit
loads
tophats
hungary
jigga
voyeurdorm
turpentine
foundation
monopoly
social
suspender
bodice
mirages
chrome
smeagol
salerno
prepress
buju
suprax
crowd
calamondin
imc
hol
ankara
rahman
oxiclean
damiana
mat
electromagnet
emanuelle
csc
adultery
aneurism
funhouse
aiu
trinkets
arnette
airboats
limite
hotrods
chieftains
sensuality
hoppy
sculpting
tingle
seasalt
Комментариев нет:
Отправить комментарий